Reddit is not a posting queue. Sitewide rules and each community's rules both apply. Pitching blogs is a different email: how to pitch music to blogs. The release checklist (captions, first button, swap on Friday): music release promotion checklist. This page is how a US indie artist uses Reddit without getting removed for spam.
Sitewide rules first
Reddit's Reddit Rules, Rule 2: abide by community rules, participate authentically in communities where you have a personal interest, and do not spam.
The official Spam policy (updated October 30, 2026 on Reddit Help) defines spam as repeated or unsolicited actions that negatively affect users, communities, or Reddit. It calls out mass-posting repetitive content for exposure or financial gain, mass-tagging or unsolicited chats, and using bots. To avoid being labeled a spammer, Reddit says:
- Post authentic content in communities where you have a personal interest.
- If your contributions are primarily links to a business you run, own, or benefit from, be thoughtful about frequency, or use Reddit's advertising tools.
- Check that community's rules. Moderators decide what is unwanted there.
There is no sitewide numeric "10% of posts" cap in that spam article. Some communities do use a 10% / 9:1 style rule. Reddit's older, user-written Reddiquette still mentions a 9:1 rule of thumb (about 1 in 10 submissions your own content). Treat Reddiquette as informal culture, not a substitute for the sidebar.
Read the subreddit before you post
Open the community → About / Rules. Look for words like self-promo, original content, feedback, weekly thread, no advertising, no Bandcamp. Rules change. A screenshot from 2022 is not current policy.
Patterns you will actually see (always confirm on the live page):
- No self-promotion at all. Some musician and gear communities ban advertising your music, events, or channels. Don't "just this once."
- Weekly feedback or share threads only. Your song belongs as a comment in that thread, on the day it is stickied, with whatever format they ask (genre, one link, no streaming-service spam).
- Original content allowed with a title formula. Some genre or city communities allow a post if you tag it [OC], name the city, or include a streaming link they specify. Follow the template exactly.
- Rate-your-band / feedback rooms. These exist so you get notes, not playlist adds. Ask a specific question ("does the chorus land") and take the notes without arguing.
Search the subreddit for "weekly" and "feedback" before you compose a standalone post. If the weekly thread is the rule, a new top-level post is the violation.
Etiquette that keeps the account usable
- Comment on other people's work in that community for a while before you drop a link. "Authentic participation" is the sitewide standard.
- One community at a time, not the same text in ten genre subs in ten minutes. That is the mass-posting pattern Reddit's spam policy describes.
- Don't ask for upvotes, in the post or off-site. Don't vote with extra accounts.
- Don't DM people who commented on a similar song. Unsolicited chat is in the spam examples.
- If mods remove it, read the removal note. Don't immediately repost. Don't argue in modmail past one polite clarification.
What to link
When a thread allows a link, give people one page that already has a first button:
- This song (Spotify / Apple Music / Bandcamp labeled)
- A live clip, if they asked to hear the band
- Nothing else required for a feedback comment
Don't paste six store URLs, a Discord invite, a merch drop, and a pre-save in one comment. Don't use a URL shortener to hide Bandcamp. Don't link a desktop-only homepage. If they asked for a private stream, use that, not the public pre-save.
Title/body that matches how a person talks: "Midwest indie three-piece, new single 'Glasshouse,' looking for mix notes on the chorus" plus the Tapfirst URL. Not all-caps "out now" with a row of store links, and not a press release. Press-release structure belongs in email: how to write a music press release.
On Tapfirst: "put [title] first." Publish free for 14 days, then $5/month. Keep that URL stable so a comment from last month still works.
FAQ
Can I post the same song in every music subreddit on release day? That is the mass-posting pattern in Reddit's spam policy. Post only where the current rules allow it, usually one weekly thread, and only if you already participate there.
Is the 10% rule official? Not as a sitewide number in the current spam article. Some communities use it; Reddiquette mentions 9:1 as a rule of thumb. The sidebar of the subreddit you are in is the rule that can get you banned from that community.
Should the Reddit post go to Bandcamp only? Only if that community asked for Bandcamp. Otherwise one page with streaming and Bandcamp together avoids losing people who only use Spotify. Why a Bandcamp-only bio is a problem elsewhere: Bandcamp-only bio link.
Make a page for your music
Describe the release and add the one listen link a feedback thread would need. Review the first draft, then ask for changes in chat. Start at tapfirst.link.